How to price AI credits for power users
A flat AI plan looks fine until a small share of customers uses it ten times harder. Here is the arithmetic, and three ways to stop paying for it yourself.
Short answer
A $19 flat plan where a normal account uses 200 actions at $0.08 each earns $3 gross profit per account. If 10% of accounts use 10× as much, the blended result is an $11.40 gross loss per account. Fix it with a smaller included allowance plus a hard cap, paid overage above the allowance, or outcome pricing.
Which usage actually costs you money
Only served work incurs provider cost: tokens processed, minutes generated, images rendered. Requests blocked by a hard cap cost nothing. An included allowance, by contrast, is just a billing threshold — usage under it is still served and still costs you, you just don't charge extra for it.
So a plan's real exposure is set by the cap (or lack of one), not by the allowance.
Three levers
Pick the lightest one that protects margin for the heavy cohort.
- Smaller allowance with a hard cap: e.g. 250 actions included, capped at 600. Worst-case cost per account is 600 × $0.08 = $48, and you can price the plan with that in mind.
- Charged overage: include 200 actions, then $0.10 per extra action. A 2,000-action user pays $19 + $180 = $199 against $160 of cost.
- Outcome pricing: when users only value successful results (a resolved ticket, an accepted edit), charge per outcome and budget for failed attempts.
Worked example: “Flat plan under load”
- Normal account: $19 revenue − 200 × $0.08 = $3.00 gross profit.
- Power account (10×): $19 − 2,000 × $0.08 = −$141.00.
- Blend with 90% normal and 10% power: 0.9 × $3 + 0.1 × (−$141) = −$11.40 per account.
- In the simulator the Solo tier flips from positive to negative when you toggle the heavy-user spike (10% tail, 10×, 0% buffer).
- Try adding a hard cap of 400 on Solo: the power cohort is limited to $32 of cost and the tier returns to profit.
| Cohort | Share of accounts | Served actions | Cost (USD) | Gross profit (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Normal | 90% | 200 | $16.00 | $3.00 |
| Power (10×, no cap) | 10% | 2,000 | $160.00 | −$141.00 |
| Blended | 100% | 380 avg | $30.40 | −$11.40 |
| Power with 400 cap | 10% | 400 | $32.00 | −$13.00 |
| Blended with 400 cap | 100% | 220 avg | $17.60 | $1.40 |
Questions founders ask
Should a cap feel like a punishment?
No. Say the limit on the pricing page, warn at 80%, and offer the next tier or a top-up at the moment someone hits it. A visible cap is a buying signal, not a wall.
What buffer should I add for variable cost?
Use the stress buffer to cover provider price changes, retries and longer outputs from heavy users. The default is +20%; this example uses 0% to keep the arithmetic exact.